United’s Reset Shines Light on Their Next Permanent Manager

The Challenge of Finding the Right Manager for Manchester United

As Manchester United embarks on the process of appointing a new head coach, one factor stands out above all others: the manager’s ability to make a strong impression from the moment they step through the door. This might seem like a simple idea, but it has proven to be incredibly important in the past.

The club’s leadership, particularly Sir Jim Ratcliffe, initially believed that Ruben Amorim had the personality and charisma to handle the immense pressure of managing such a storied club. However, over time, sources have suggested that they came to believe he lacked the emotional maturity required to lead the team effectively. In short, he wasn’t ready.

This issue remains relevant despite the ever-changing nature of modern football. It is also a challenge that Manchester United now faces—perhaps even more so due to the economic conditions that have long benefited the club.

The truth is that there are fewer top-tier coaches available than ever before. If you look at the 12 clubs that were part of the Super League initiative, which was essentially a group of wealthy teams aiming for the biggest trophies, you’ll find that more managers have won nothing at all than those who have won the Champions League. Only Pep Guardiola and Hansi Flick have lifted the trophy, and if you include Luis Enrique as a potential candidate from Paris Saint-Germain, Bayern Munich, and Borussia Dortmund, that number increases to three.

This situation is almost the opposite of what it was a decade ago. Back then, Guardiola was the obvious choice for every club, while Manchester United could turn to a legendary figure like Jose Mourinho. Of that 2016 “summer of super coaches,” only Guardiola remains. Meanwhile, Michael Carrick is now preparing a game plan to face the Catalan coach on Saturday.

Modern football has created a self-perpetuating cycle where the growing gap between the wealthiest clubs makes it increasingly difficult for coaches to gain the necessary experience or credentials to manage them.

This dynamic helps explain why there is renewed talk about Manchester United returning to Thomas Tuchel, who nearly joined the club in the summer of 2024. He has the charisma, the record, and sufficiently modern ideas—but his availability could cost the club another summer, given his desire to remain involved in the World Cup until July 19.

Luis Enrique is also being considered. Beyond that, however, many other candidates carry similar risks to Amorim. How would someone like Andoni Iraola adapt?

United sources insist that there is one crucial difference from Amorim’s arrival—and it lies on the other side of the door he walked through.

The culture and atmosphere at Carrington are said to be “night and day” compared to when Amorim first arrived. This is not just an internal claim; it is echoed by other figures in the game, including those from rival clubs who have visited the training base.

The hope is that this change will give Amorim’s successor a much better chance, given that the environment he first entered was described as “toxic.”

The article above is an excerpt from the members-only Friday edition of the Miguel Delaney: Inside Football newsletter. To unlock the full article and get my latest reporting, insight, and commentary delivered straight to your inbox, become a member here. A free edition is also sent on Mondays—you can sign up to this using the box at the top of this article. You can also head to our newsletter preference centre to sign up for the free email. Once there, all you need to do is press the ‘+’ button and enter your email address.

The Independent is the world’s most free-thinking news brand, providing global news, commentary, and analysis for the independently-minded. We have grown a huge, global readership of independently minded individuals, who value our trusted voice and commitment to positive change. Our mission, making change happen, has never been as important as it is today.